DNA results Rameses III shows African haplogroup

[samuel]

I think the polemic though is where Afro asiatic was born. They believe now that it was born in Africa. East or central Africa to be precise.

[melanitex]

Jun 2, 2016 14:16:59 GMT -5 samuel said:

I think the polemic though is where Afro asiatic was born. They believe now that it was born in Africa. East or central Africa to be precise.

With all due respect Samuel that's kind of irrelevant because why is Sudan mainly concentrated with Nilotic people whom are Nilo Saharan speakers who have entirely different genetics to West African E1B1A carriers?? 

Look at this picture does that look like the Horn of Africa or North-East Africa to you?? If AE and Ramses III was truly E1b1a then the Black people of Aswan as well as the Nubian area should also be E1b1a too right? This is basic common sense, but they aren't.... There are only two logical explanations:

1) The original E1b1a Egyptians and Nubians fled into West and South Africa as the Map shows and were repopulated by a new wave of Black Africans in Aswan and Nubia who are entirely different to them genetically.

2) The test is wrong.

I am inclined to go with the latter.....

[snakepit]

Jun 3, 2016 15:05:51 GMT -5 melanitex said:

Jun 2, 2016 14:16:59 GMT -5 samuel said:

I think the polemic though is where Afro asiatic was born. They believe now that it was born in Africa. East or central Africa to be precise.

With all due respect Samuel that's kind of irrelevant because why is Sudan mainly concentrated with Nilotic people whom are Nilo Saharan speakers who have entirely different genetics to West African E1B1A carriers?? 

Look at this picture does that look like the Horn of Africa or North-East Africa to you?? If AE and Ramses III was truly E1b1a then the Black people of Aswan as well as the Nubian area should also be E1b1a too right? This is basic common sense, but they aren't.... There are only two logical explanations:

1) The original E1b1a Egyptians and Nubians fled into West and South Africa as the Map shows and were repopulated by a new wave of Black Africans in Aswan and Nubia who are entirely different to them genetically.

2) The test is wrong.

I am inclined to go with the latter.....

None of the above. Kmt was a multi-ethnic society, made up of several different (African) ethnicities. So Ramesses III happened to be E1b1a, so what? The entire population of Kmt didn't have to belong to the same dna-haplogroups (both Y-dna and mtdna) , that doesn't make any sense at all. The test is correct, as DNA Tribes used the data retrieved by Hawass' team, there's no spooky stuff going on here.